Complete Summary and Solutions for The Enemy – NCERT Class XII VISTAS Supplementary Reader, Chapter 4 – Story Summary, Explanation, Questions, Answers
Detailed summary and explanation of Chapter 4 'The Enemy' by Pearl S. Buck from the NCERT Class XII VISTAS Supplementary Reader. The story revolves around Dr. Sadao, a Japanese doctor, who finds an American prisoner of war and is conflicted between his medical duty and national loyalty amid World War tensions—along with all NCERT questions, answers, and exercises.
Updated: 27 seconds ago

The Enemy
Pearl S. Buck | Vistas Prose - Ultimate Study Guide 2025
Introduction to the Story
"The Enemy" is a poignant wartime tale exploring the moral conflict between patriotism and humanity. Set during World War II on the Japanese coast, it follows Dr. Sadao Hoki, a renowned surgeon, who discovers an injured American prisoner of war washed ashore. Torn between his duty as a doctor to save lives and his obligation as a Japanese patriot to report the enemy, Sadao grapples with profound ethical dilemmas. With his wife Hana's support, he secretly operates on and hides the man, risking arrest and execution. The story culminates in Sadao's decision to aid the prisoner's escape, affirming the universal bond of human compassion over national enmity.
Key Elements
- Setting: Isolated Japanese seaside home amid WWII tensions.
- Narrator: Third-person omniscient, delving into Sadao's internal turmoil.
- Theme Preview: Humanism vs. nationalism; the healing power transcends borders.
Context in Vistas
This narrative highlights ethical choices in conflict, aligning with CBSE's emphasis on moral philosophy for 2025 exams.
Points to Ponder
- Can professional duty override national loyalty?
- How does fear influence moral decisions in wartime?
Reprint 2025-26
About the Author: Pearl S. Buck (1892–1973)
Biography
Pearl S. Buck, born in West Virginia, spent much of her life in China as a missionary's daughter. She won the Pulitzer Prize for "The Good Earth" (1931) and the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1938 for her empathetic portrayals of Asian life. "The Enemy," published in 1942, reflects her experiences with cultural clashes and humanism during global conflicts.
Legacy
Buck's works bridge East-West divides, advocating for cross-cultural understanding. Her focus on ordinary lives amid extraordinary circumstances influenced global literature on war and ethics.
Worldview
Buck's narratives, informed by her China residency, emphasize compassion's triumph over prejudice, resonant in today's divided world.
Expanded Bio
Adopted children from Asia and founded organizations for intercultural exchange; her writing career spanned novels, biographies, and activism.
Reprint 2025-26
Before You Read
It is the time of the World War. An American prisoner of war is washed ashore in a dying state and is found at the doorstep of a Japanese doctor. Should he save him as a doctor or hand him over to the Army as a patriot?
This dilemma sets the stage for exploring the tension between professional ethics and national duty, prompting readers to consider personal values in crisis.
Who was Dr Sadao? Where was his house?
Dr. Sadao Hoki is a skilled Japanese surgeon; his house is a low, square stone structure on the Japanese coast, above a narrow beach lined with bent pines.
Pre-Reading Thoughts
- What role does setting play in amplifying isolation and moral isolation?
- Buck invites empathy for "enemies" through shared humanity.
Reprint 2025-26
Full Text & Summary
Summary (English)
In Pearl S. Buck's "The Enemy," set during World War II, Dr. Sadao Hoki, a celebrated Japanese surgeon, resides in a secluded coastal home built by his father, symbolizing Japan's imperial ambitions. Trained in America, Sadao marries Hana, whom he meets there, blending Western knowledge with Japanese traditions. One foggy evening, as mists envelop their home, Sadao and Hana spot a figure stumbling from the sea—a wounded white man, an escaped American POW from the U.S. Navy, shot in the back. Despite the war's enmity, Sadao's Hippocratic oath compels him to staunch the bleeding with sea moss and carry the unconscious sailor indoors, debating whether to report him or let him die. Hana, torn between fear for their family and compassion, urges practicality, yet both hesitate to drown him as the "kindest" act. Identifying him as an enemy, Sadao rationalizes his aid as mere professional duty, planning to hand him over once healed. The servants—Yumi, the gardener, and cook—react with horror and superstition, refusing to wash the "dirty" foreigner and quitting in protest, leaving Hana to clean him herself, revealing his youthful blond features. Sadao, equipped with his surgical kit, operates under dim light, extracting the bullet while Hana administers anesthesia, her hands trembling at the sight of blood. The General, Sadao's patient, blackmails him into secrecy by promising private assassins if the American is reported, binding Sadao to hide the man in his father's unused room. Days pass in tense secrecy; the POW, Tom, awakens, revealing his simple farm-boy origins from Vermont, contrasting Sadao's educated life. Hana warms to him through shared meals, but Sadao remains conflicted, his patriotism clashing with empathy. As Tom recovers, Sadao procures a boat and supplies, arranging his escape under cover of night. When soldiers search the house, the General's assurance holds, but Sadao realizes the fragility of his position. Tom rows away safely, leaving a note of gratitude. Sadao reflects on the enemy's humanity, pondering if future generations will judge such acts. Buck masterfully weaves internal monologues with vivid coastal imagery—crashing waves, creeping fogs—to underscore isolation's moral crucible. The narrative critiques wartime dehumanization, affirming medicine's borderless vow. Through Sadao's evolution from revulsion to reluctant kinship, it posits compassion as patriotism's truest form, resonant in an era of global conflicts. Hana's quiet strength and the servants' prejudice highlight societal pressures on individual ethics. Ultimately, "The Enemy" transcends propaganda, urging readers to question enmity's roots and heal life's divides with empathy's scalpel.
सारांश (हिंदी)
पर्ल एस. बक की "द एनमी" द्वितीय विश्व युद्ध के दौरान सेट एक मार्मिक युद्धकालीन कथा है, जो देशभक्ति और मानवता के बीच नैतिक द्वंद्व की पड़ताल करती है। प्रसिद्ध जापानी शल्य चिकित्सक डॉ. सादाओ होकी अपने पिता द्वारा निर्मित एक एकांत तटीय घर में रहते हैं, जो जापान की साम्राज्यवादी महत्वाकांक्षाओं का प्रतीक है। अमेरिका में प्रशिक्षित सादाओ वहां हाना से मिलते हैं और विवाह करते हैं, पश्चिमी ज्ञान को जापानी परंपराओं के साथ मिश्रित करते हैं। एक कोहरे भरी शाम, जब कोहरा उनके घर को घेर लेता है, सादाओ और हाना समुद्र से एक आकृति को ठोकरते हुए देखते हैं—एक घायल गोरा आदमी, अमेरिकी नौसेना से भागा हुआ युद्धबंदी, पीठ में गोली लगी हुई। युद्ध की शत्रुता के बावजूद, सादाओ का हिप्पोक्रेटिक शपथ उन्हें रक्त रोकने के लिए समुद्री काई का उपयोग करने और बेहोश नाविक को घर में ले जाने के लिए बाध्य करती है, रिपोर्ट करने या मरने देने के बीच बहस करते हुए। हाना, परिवार के लिए भय और करुणा के बीच फंसी, व्यावहारिकता की सलाह देती है, फिर भी दोनों डुबोने के "दयालु" कार्य पर हिचकिचाते हैं। उसे शत्रु के रूप में पहचानते हुए, सादाओ अपनी सहायता को मात्र पेशेवर कर्तव्य बताते हैं, ठीक होने पर सौंपने की योजना बनाते हैं। नौकर—यूमी, माली और रसोइया—डर और अंधविश्वास से प्रतिक्रिया देते हैं, "गंदे" विदेशी को धोने से इनकार करते हैं और विरोध में नौकरी छोड़ देते हैं, हाना को खुद साफ करने को छोड़ते हुए, उसके युवा सुनहरे बालों का खुलासा करते हैं। सादाओ, अपने शल्य उपकरण से लैस, मंद रोशनी में ऑपरेशन करते हैं, गोली निकालते हुए जबकि हाना एनेस्थीसिया देती है, रक्त देखकर उसके हाथ कांपते हैं। सादाओ के मरीज जनरल, अमेरिकी को रिपोर्ट करने पर निजी हत्यारों का वादा करके उन्हें चुप रहने के लिए ब्लैकमेल करते हैं, सादाओ को अपने पिता के अप्रयुक्त कमरे में छिपाने बाध्य करते हैं। तनावपूर्ण गोपनीयता में दिन बीतते हैं; युद्धबंदी टॉम जागता है, वर्मॉंट के साधारण किसान मूल का खुलासा करता है, सादाओ के शिक्षित जीवन से विपरीत। हाना साझा भोजन के माध्यम से उसके प्रति नरम पड़ती है, लेकिन सादाओ द्वंद्व में फंसे रहते हैं, उनकी देशभक्ति सहानुभूति से टकराती है। जैसे-जैसे टॉम ठीक होता है, सादाओ नाव और सामान जुटाते हैं, रात के अंधेरे में उसकी भागने की व्यवस्था करते हैं। जब सैनिक घर की तलाशी लेते हैं, जनरल का आश्वासन टिकता है, लेकिन सादाओ अपनी स्थिति की नाजुकता समझते हैं। टॉम सुरक्षित कूच करता है, कृतज्ञता का नोट छोड़कर। सादाओ शत्रु की मानवता पर चिंतन करते हैं, सोचते हैं कि भविष्य की पीढ़ियां ऐसे कार्यों का न्याय करेंगी। बक आंतरिक संवादों को जीवंत तटीय चित्रण—टकराती लहरें, रेंगते कोहरे—के साथ बुनती हैं, नैतिक भट्टी में एकांत को रेखांकित करने के लिए। कथा युद्धकालीन अमानवीकरण की आलोचना करती है, चिकित्सा की सीमाहीन प्रतिज्ञा की पुष्टि करती है। सादाओ के घृणा से अनिच्छुक रिश्तेदारी तक विकास के माध्यम से, यह करुणा को देशभक्ति का सच्चा रूप बताती है, वैश्विक संघर्षों के युग में प्रतिध्वनित। हाना की शांत ताकत और नौकरों की पूर्वाग्रह सामाजिक दबावों पर व्यक्तिगत नैतिकता को उजागर करते हैं। अंततः, "द एनमी" प्रचार से ऊपर उठती है, शत्रुता की जड़ों पर सवाल उठाती है और सहानुभूति के स्कैल्पेल से जीवन के विभाजनों को भरने को प्रेरित करती है।
Full Text (From Provided PDF Pages)
Key Imagery
- Fog and mists: Symbolize moral ambiguity and isolation.
- Wound and surgery: Represent healing amid conflict.
- Sea and rocks: Evoke nature's indifference to human divides.
Reprint 2025-26
Glossary
- Haori: A loose outer garment worn over the kimono, traditional Japanese attire.
- Tokonoma: An alcove in a Japanese home for displaying art or flowers.
- Hippocratic oath: Ethical pledge for physicians to prioritize patient care above all.
Additional Terms
- POW: Prisoner of War; captured enemy soldier.
- Stanch: To stop or check the flow of blood.
- Superstitious: Believing in omens or supernatural influences, as with the servants.
Reprint 2025-26
Understanding the Story
Plot Overview
From discovery and surgery to hiding and escape, the linear plot builds tension through Sadao's ethical evolution and external threats like servants and soldiers.
Characters
- Dr. Sadao Hoki: Protagonist; surgeon embodying duty's conflict.
- Hana: Loyal wife; supports despite fear, humanizing the enemy.
- Tom (POW): Innocent American; catalyst for moral awakening.
- General: Antagonist figure; represents corrupt authority.
Narrative Style
Third-person limited focuses on Sadao's psyche, using sensory details to immerse readers in emotional and ethical fog.
Setting Details
The coastal isolation amplifies internal drama, with the sea as both destroyer and deliverer.
Reprint 2025-26
Themes & Critical Analysis
Central Themes
- Humanity vs. Patriotism: Saving an enemy challenges national loyalty.
- Ethical Dilemma: Doctor's oath in wartime tests universal morals.
- Compassion's Triumph: Shared suffering dissolves enmity.
Sub-Themes
- Cultural Clash: Sadao's American education vs. Japanese duty.
- Gender Roles: Hana's quiet resilience contrasts societal expectations.
Critical Appreciation
Buck's nuanced portrayal avoids stereotypes, using irony (General's aid) to critique war's absurdities and affirm empathy's enduring power.
Deeper Analysis
Symbolism: The bullet represents entrenched hate; extraction signifies liberation.
Cultural Context: Written amid WWII, it humanizes the "other" side.
- Relevance: Speaks to modern refugee crises and ethical aid debates.
Discussion Prompts
- Is Sadao's aid treason or true patriotism?
- How does prejudice manifest in the servants' reactions?
Reprint 2025-26
Reading with Insight
1. Do you think Sadao’s character is pleased or ashamed of his ability to save the enemy?
Sadao feels a mix of pride in his skill and shame in aiding an enemy, evolving to quiet satisfaction in his humanitarian act.
2. Why does Hana help the wounded man even though she has no professional obligation?
Hana aids out of empathy and marital loyalty, overriding fear to affirm shared humanity beyond war's divides.
3. Why do you think the General does not get the man killed?
The General relies on Sadao's surgical expertise for his health, pragmatically sparing the POW to secure his own care.
4. Why does the servant leave Sadao’s house?
Yumi leaves due to prejudice and superstition, refusing to serve an "enemy" and fearing retribution.
5. How does the author show the difference between a Japanese and an American mindset?
Through Sadao's duty-bound hesitation vs. Tom's casual gratitude, highlighting cultural contrasts in formality and directness.
Reprint 2025-26
Interactive Quiz - Test Your Understanding
10 MCQs on the story, themes, and analysis. Aim for 80%+!
Suggested Reading
Buck's Works
- The Good Earth – Epic on Chinese peasant life.
- Imperial Woman – Historical tale of China's last empress.
More
- Related: Erich Maria Remarque's "All Quiet on the Western Front"; ethical war stories.
- Essays: On medical ethics in conflicts.
Reprint 2025-26
Group Discussions
No forum posts available.
Easily Share with Your Tribe


