Complete Summary and Solutions for The Lament – Woven Words NCERT Class XI English Elective, Chapter 1 – Summary, Explanation, Questions, Answers
A detailed summary and explanation of Anton Chekhov’s short story "The Lament," portraying the poignant tale of Iona Potapov, a cabdriver in twilight, as he struggles with grief and loneliness after the death of his son. Includes all NCERT questions, answers, and comprehension exercises from the Woven Words Elective Course for Class XI.
Updated: just now

The Lament
Anton Chekhov | Woven Words Short Stories - Ultimate Study Guide 2025
Introduction to Short Stories - Woven Words
A short story is a brief work of prose fiction. It has a plot which may be comic, tragic, romantic or satiric; the story is presented to us from one of the many available points of view, and it may be written in the mode of fantasy, realism or naturalism.
In the ‘story of incident’ the focus of interest is on the course and outcome of events, as in the Sherlock Holmes story. The ‘story of character’ focuses on the state of mind and motivation, or on the psychological and moral qualities of the protagonist, as in Glory at Twilight. Chekhov’s The Lament focuses on form—nothing happens, or seems to happen, except an encounter and conversations, but the story becomes a revelation of deep sorrow.
The short story differs from the novel in magnitude. The limitation of length imposes economy of management and in literary effects. However, a short story can also attain a fairly long and complex form, where it approaches the expansiveness of the novel, which you may find in The Third and Final Continent in this unit.
Key Elements
- Plot Patterns: Comic, tragic, romantic, satiric.
- Points of View: Multiple perspectives in fantasy, realism, naturalism.
- Types: Story of incident (events), story of character (psychology).
- Economy: Brevity demands concise management and effects.
Reprint 2025-26
Author: Anton Chekhov (1860–1904)
Anton Chekhov was born in a middle-class family in Russia. He studied medicine at Moscow University. His first short story appeared in 1880 and, in the next seven years, he produced more than six hundred stories. He also wrote plays—Seagull, Uncle Vanya, The Three Sisters and The Cherry Orchard are among the more famous ones. His work greatly influenced the modern short story and drama.
The main theme of Chekhov’s short stories is life’s pathos, caused by the inability of human beings to respond to, or even to communicate with, one another. The present story illustrates this point beautifully.
Major Works
- Over 600 short stories (1880-1887)
- Plays: The Seagull, Uncle Vanya, The Three Sisters, The Cherry Orchard
Key Themes
- Human isolation and failed communication
- Life's quiet pathos and everyday sorrow
- Psychological depth in ordinary lives
Style
Realistic, subtle; focuses on form over action, revealing inner turmoil through dialogue and inaction.
Reprint 2025-26
Full Story Text: The Lament
Reprint 2025-26
Story Summary: English & Hindi (Detailed Overview)
English Summary (Approx. 1.5 Pages)
In a snowy twilight, grieving cabdriver Iona Potapov and his motionless horse wait for fares amid urban chaos. Snow-covered and phantom-like, Iona yearns to share his sorrow over his son's recent death from fever. An officer hires him but dismisses his halting attempt to speak, urging haste instead.
Later, three rowdy young men board for a cheap ride, mocking Iona's cap and driving, swatting him like a pest. Amid their banter and brawls, Iona tries again to mention his loss; the humpbacked one sighs indifferently, "We must all die," before they vanish into the night, reigniting his isolation.
Desperate, Iona approaches a hall porter, but is shooed away. In the stables, a young driver ignores his plea for conversation. Overwhelmed, Iona confides fully in his silent, understanding horse—the only listener—pouring out the illness, funeral, and lingering pain, finding solace in its quiet empathy.
हिंदी सारांश (संक्षिप्त)
बर्फीले सांझ में, शोकाकुल कैब चालक Ioना पोटापोव और उसका स्थिर घोड़ा किराए का इंतजार करते हैं। बर्फ से सफेद, भूत-सा Ioना अपने बेटे की हाल ही की बुखार से मौत का दर्द बांटना चाहता है। एक अधिकारी उसे किराए पर लेता है लेकिन बात को टाल देता है।
फिर तीन शोर मचाते युवक सस्ते में सवार होते हैं, Ioना का मजाक उड़ाते, उसे मारते। Ioना फिर कोशिश करता है; कूबड़ वाला उदासीनता से कहता, "सबको मरना है," और चले जाते, Ioना को अकेला छोड़।
Ioना हॉल पोर्टर से बात करने की कोशिश करता, लेकिन भगा दिया जाता। अस्तबल में युवा चालक अनसुना कर सो जाता। Ioना अंत में अपने चुप, समझदार घोड़े से पूरा दर्द बांटता—बीमारी, अंतिम संस्कार, पीड़ा—उसकी सहानुभूति में सांत्वना पाता।
Reprint 2025-26
Plot Summary: Key Events & Structure
Overview
The story unfolds in a single snowy evening, tracing Iona's futile attempts to voice his grief, culminating in catharsis with his horse. Central conflict: Human indifference vs. unspoken sorrow, emphasizing isolation in a bustling city.
Structure in Phases
- Exposition: Snowy setting, Iona's frozen grief and wait (Opening description).
- Rising Action: Officer fare (dismissal), young men (mockery), porter (rejection).
- Climax: Stables' ignored plea, overwhelming need to speak.
- Resolution: Confession to horse, emotional release.
Points to Ponder
- Symbolism: Snow = emotional numbness; horse = silent companionship.
- Narrative Voice: Third-person limited, mirroring Iona's inner turmoil.
- Cultural Insight: Russian urban alienation, Chekhov's pathos in mundane lives.
Tip: Note circular structure—begins/ends with Iona and horse, underscoring bond.
Understanding the Text
1. Comment on the indifference that meets Iona’s attempts to share his grief with his fellow human beings.
- Throughout the story, Iona's profound loss is met with a chilling lack of empathy, underscoring Chekhov's theme of human disconnection. The officer responds with a curt "Hm! What did he die of?" before immediately shifting to complaints about the drive, prioritizing his schedule over Iona's vulnerability. This mirrors the urban haste where personal tragedies are irrelevant interruptions.
- The three young men exacerbate this indifference; their rowdy banter and physical abuse ("I'll bone your neck for you!") drown out Iona's murmur of "My son… died this week." The humpback's dismissive sigh, "We must all die," reduces universal mortality to a platitude, showing superficial acknowledgment without genuine engagement. Their laughter and mockery highlight class-based disdain for the elderly cabdriver.
- Even the hall porter brushes him off with "Past nine. What are you standing here for? Move on," treating Iona as an obstacle rather than a person in pain. In the stables, the young cabdriver falls asleep mid-conversation, his thirst for water overriding Iona's thirst for connection. This cumulative rejection builds a poignant critique of societal isolation, where grief is invisible amid the "hurrying people" and "unceasing noise." Chekhov uses these encounters to reveal how modern life fosters emotional barriers, leaving individuals like Iona trapped in silence.
2. What impression of the character of Iona do you get from this story?
- Iona emerges as a profoundly tragic and resilient figure, embodying quiet human suffering in Chekhov's realistic portrayal. Described as a "phantom" bent double under snow and sorrow, he symbolizes emotional paralysis—immobile not just physically but spiritually, as his grief "conceal[s] itself in such an insignificant shell." Yet, his persistence in seeking listeners reveals a desperate humanity; he twists his mouth into a "smile" to share his pain, showing vulnerability masked by forced cheer.
- His humor amid abuse ("He-he... what gay young gentlemen!") suggests a coping mechanism, a fragile defense against loneliness that humanizes him further. Iona's tenderness toward his horse—comparing their losses and noting its "bright eyes"—contrasts his stoic endurance, highlighting innate compassion. Economically strained ("I have not even earned my fodder"), he regrets not his grief but his idleness, portraying a dutiful everyman whose moral depth shines in overlooked moments.
- Overall, Iona evokes pity and admiration: a microcosm of the ordinary Russian underclass, resilient yet broken, whose unvoiced story critiques societal neglect. Chekhov crafts him not as a victim but as a poignant lens on universal isolation, making readers reflect on their own overlooked pains.
3. How does the horse serve as a true friend and companion to Iona?
- The horse stands as Iona's sole anchor of empathy in a world of rejection, its silent presence a stark counterpoint to human callousness. From the opening, both are "quite white" and "motionless," mirroring shared immobility in grief—the horse's "angularity" and "wooden-looking legs" evoke a kindred phantom-like existence, plunged in "deep thought" amid the city's chaos.
- Unlike fares who interrupt or ignore, the horse "understands" intuitively: it "starts off at a trot" toward the stables at Iona's unspoken cue and "munches, listens and breathes over its master’s hand" during his confession. This non-verbal bond allows Iona's full catharsis—"he tells the little horse the whole story"—free from judgment, fulfilling his need to recount "every detail" of the illness, funeral, and daughter Anissia.
- Symbolically, the horse represents unconditional companionship, contrasting the "slough" of indifferent humanity. Iona's analogy ("Now let’s say you had a foal... It would be sad, wouldn’t it?") humanizes it, forging a maternal parallel that heals his isolation. In Chekhov's pathos-driven narrative, this interspecies friendship underscores a profound truth: true connection often lies beyond words, in quiet, unwavering presence.
Talking about the Text - Discussion Prompts
Discuss in pairs or small groups
1. Empathy and understanding are going out of modern society. The individual experiences intense alienation from the society around him or her.
- Iona's repeated dismissals exemplify how urban anonymity erodes empathy; the "hurrying people" and "hub[b]ub of the street" parallel today's fast-paced digital world, where notifications trump deep listening. Explore: Does technology amplify this alienation, as seen in superficial social media interactions versus genuine dialogue?
- Real-life parallels: Post-pandemic loneliness studies show rising isolation; service workers like cabdrivers often bear hidden griefs unseen by passengers. Chekhov's 19th-century Russia foreshadows this—discuss how economic pressures (Iona's "fodder" worry) compound emotional voids.
- Broader implications: The story critiques capitalism's dehumanization, where individuals are "scoundrels" in a jostling crowd. Counter-solutions? Role of community spaces or therapy in rebuilding empathy; animals/pets as modern "horses" filling relational gaps.
- Personal reflection: Share experiences of feeling unheard—how does Iona's arc inspire active listening in daily life?
2. Behind the public face of the people in various occupations is a whole saga of personal suffering and joy which they wish to share with others.
- Iona's cab hides a "immense, illimitable" grief, while the officer's authority masks impatience and the young men's bravado conceals hangovers and lies. This layers Chekhov's realism: professions as facades for inner lives. Discuss: How do roles like cabdriver or student enforce silence on personal sagas?
- Barriers to sharing: Class divides (young men's abuse), time constraints (officer's haste), and cultural stoicism in Russian society suppress vulnerability. Modern angle: Gig economy workers' isolation—Uber drivers today echo Iona's unseen pains.
- Consequences and bridges: Unshared joy/suffering breeds pathos, as in Iona's "rends his heart"; small acts like pausing for conversation can heal. Explore gender dynamics—Iona notes women "sob" easily, hinting at emotional openness variances.
- Creative extension: Role-play scenarios where characters swap stories—how might empathy shift the narrative? Tie to global issues: Mental health stigma in workplaces.
Appreciation & Analysis
1. The story begins with a description of the setting. How does this serve as a fitting prelude to the events described in the story?
- The vivid, sensory opening—"thick wet snow... twirling around the newly lighted street lamps"—immerses readers in a liminal twilight world, blending beauty and desolation to mirror Iona's psyche. Snow's "soft thin layers" on "roofs, horses’ backs, people’s shoulders" evokes a smothering blanket, foreshadowing grief's invisibility and the protagonist's "phantom"-like numbness.
- This prelude establishes thematic duality: Urban "slough" of "monstrous lights" and "unceasing noise" contrasts the horse's rural "plough" origins, symbolizing displacement and alienation. The pair's immobility amid motion primes the plot's inertia—nothing "happens" externally, yet inner revelation brews, aligning with Chekhov's "story of character."
- Atmospherically, white's cold purity sets a tone of frozen sorrow, recurring in Iona's failed shakes of snow (like unshakeable pain). It preludes rejection sequences by humanizing the environment as indifferent, preparing readers for the emotional crescendo in the stables.
2. Comment on the graphic detail with which the various passengers who took Iona’s cab are described.
- Chekhov's meticulous, almost caricatured details vivify the passengers, heightening their indifference's cruelty against Iona's fragility. The officer—"in a greatcoat, with his hood over his head"—looms as a hooded authority figure, his "angry" calls and closed eyes embodying detached hierarchy; sensory cues like "dark mass moving to and fro" amplify chaotic intrusion.
- The young men burst with grotesque vitality: "two of them tall and lanky, the third one short and humpbacked," their "squeak of galoshes" and "cracked voice" evoke vulgar youth. Details like the humpback's "twanging voice" breathing "in Iona’s neck," "wriggling," and "six-foot oath" create tactile disgust, contrasting Iona's meek giggles—abuse feels visceral, underscoring class mockery.
- These portraits serve narrative economy: Vividness condenses character, revealing societal types (military briskness, youthful excess) without exposition. It amplifies pathos—Iona's "snuffle" against their "swearing" highlights vulnerability. Chekhov's realism shines in blending humor (their bickering) with tragedy, making rejection multifaceted and memorable.
3. This short story revolves around a single important event. Discuss how the narrative is woven around this central fact.
- The son's death anchors the narrative as a static "event," with Chekhov masterfully weaving inaction around it—episodes test Iona's communicative urges, building tension through thwarted revelations. No plot twists occur; instead, the "central fact" radiates outward, coloring every interaction: Officer ride exposes haste's blindness, young men's chaos drowns whispers, stables' silence peaks desperation.
- Form mirrors content: Brevity enforces "economy," distilling pathos from mundane fares into a revelation of sorrow. Repetition ("My son... died this week") threads the grief, escalating from "snuffle" to full outpour, unifying the arc. Flashbacks (illness, funeral) embedded in Iona's monologues expand the event temporally without disrupting flow.
- This structure exemplifies Chekhov's innovation—subverting "story of incident" for psychological depth. The "nothing happens" facade belies emotional profundity, critiquing life's overlooked tragedies. Woven thus, the narrative transforms a single loss into universal commentary on isolation, rewarding rereads with layered insights.
4. The story begins and ends with Iona and his horse. Comment on the significance of this to the plot of the story.
- The circular framing—opening with the snow-bound pair in silent vigil, closing with Iona's cathartic confession—encapsulates the plot's emotional core: constancy amid transience. This bookend reinforces the horse as thematic fulcrum, the unchanging companion weathering urban slights, symbolizing enduring bonds beyond human frailty.
- Plot-wise, it underscores isolation's arc: Initial immobility evolves to purposeful trot homeward, mirroring grief's thaw. The ending's intimacy ("breathes over its master’s hand") resolves the narrative's tension, providing closure absent in human encounters—yet the loop implies cyclical sorrow, as dawn's work awaits.
- Significantly, it elevates the horse from prop to co-protagonist, critiquing anthropocentric views: True empathy thrives in silence, not words. Chekhov's structure thus amplifies pathos, inviting reflection on overlooked relationships in life's "slough," and cementing the story's elegiac tone.
Language Work
1. Common in Form and Meaning
- Snuffle, snort, sniffle, snore: Nasal sounds/actions (onomatopoeic, related to breathing/noise from nose/mouth during emotion/sleep).
2. Classification by Closeness in Meaning
| A (Laugh Softly) | B (Move Stealthily) | C (High-Pitched Sound) | D (Mock) | E (Breathe Audibly) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| snigger, titter, chuckle, chortle, guffaw | wriggle, sneak, sidle, scramble, straggle | squeak, squawk, shriek, croak | jeer | sigh, pant, gasp, snort, plod (effortful) |
3. Associations of 'White'
- Snow: Purity, but cold isolation; covers Iona/horse like shroud—grief's numbness; contrasts urban "monstrous lights," symbolizing emotional blankness/death.
4. Phrase Explanation
- 'As if he were on needles': Extremely uncomfortable/restless (like pins pricking). Similar: 'On pins and needles' or 'On hot coals' (anxiety/agitation).
Interactive Quiz - Test Your Understanding
10 MCQs on plot, themes, and language. Aim for 80%+.
Suggested Reading
- What Men Live By by Leo Tolstoy
- The Overcoat by N. Gogol
Reprint 2025-26
Group Discussions
No forum posts available.
Easily Share with Your Tribe


