Complete Summary and Solutions for The Rocking-horse Winner – Woven Words NCERT Class XI English Elective, Chapter 3 – Summary, Explanation, Questions, Answers
A psychological short story by D.H. Lawrence, "The Rocking-horse Winner" recounts a boy named Paul who desperately tries to earn luck and money to satisfy his mother's insatiable desire for wealth, leading to tragic consequences. Includes all NCERT questions, answers, and exercises from the Woven Words Elective Course for Class XI.
Updated: 1 minute ago

The Rocking-Horse Winner
D.H. Lawrence | Woven Words Short Stories - Ultimate Study Guide 2025
Introduction to Short Stories - Woven Words
A short story is a brief work of prose fiction. It has a plot which may be comic, tragic, romantic or satiric; the story is presented to us from one of the many available points of view, and it may be written in the mode of fantasy, realism or naturalism.
In the ‘story of incident’ the focus of interest is on the course and outcome of events, as in the Sherlock Holmes story. The ‘story of character’ focuses on the state of mind and motivation, or on the psychological and moral qualities of the protagonist, as in Glory at Twilight. Lawrence’s The Rocking-Horse Winner focuses on form—nothing happens, or seems to happen, except an encounter and conversations, but the story becomes a revelation of deep sorrow.
The short story differs from the novel in magnitude. The limitation of length imposes economy of management and in literary effects. However, a short story can also attain a fairly long and complex form, where it approaches the expansiveness of the novel, which you may find in The Third and Final Continent in this unit.
Key Elements
- Plot Patterns: Comic, tragic, romantic, satiric.
- Points of View: Multiple perspectives in fantasy, realism, naturalism.
- Types: Story of incident (events), story of character (psychology).
- Economy: Brevity demands concise management and effects.
Reprint 2025-26
Author: D.H. Lawrence (1885–1930)
D.H. Lawrence (1885–1930) was born in a mining village near Nottingham in England. His father was a coal miner and his mother a genteel and ambitious lady who had worked previously as a schoolmistress. Their conflicting interests had had a powerful impact on the physical and imaginative build-up of young Lawrence.
Lawrence wrote novels, poems, short stories, criticism and miscellaneous prose. His work, at its best, is marked by intensity of feeling, psychological insight and vivid evocation of events, places and nature.
Major Works
- Novels: Sons and Lovers, The Rainbow, Women in Love
- Short Stories: The Rocking-Horse Winner, The Prussian Officer
- Poems and Criticism
Key Themes
- Psychological conflict and family dynamics
- Materialism vs. emotional fulfillment
- Intensity of human emotions and nature
Style
Realistic with symbolic elements; explores inner turmoil through vivid imagery and subtle whispers of discontent.
Reprint 2025-26
Full Story Text: The Rocking-Horse Winner
Reprint 2025-26
Story Summary: English & Hindi (Detailed Overview)
English Summary (Approx. 1.5 Pages)
In a stylish but money-haunted home, a beautiful yet unlucky mother struggles with unfulfilled love and financial anxiety, haunted by the unspoken whisper: "There must be more money!" Her son Paul, sensing this void, declares himself lucky and obsessively rides his rocking-horse to divine race winners, partnering with gardener Bassett and Uncle Oscar for secret bets that yield fortunes.
Paul's frenzied rides predict victors like Daffodil and Lively Spark, amassing thousands anonymously gifted to his mother via yearly installments. Yet, her insatiable desires amplify the whispers, driving Paul to desperation before the Derby. Overwrought, he collapses mid-trance, naming Malabar as the winner in delirium. The horse triumphs, securing eighty thousand pounds, but Paul dies from brain-fever, his sacrificial "luck" exposing materialism's tragic cost.
The tale critiques greed's psychological toll, with the rocking-horse symbolizing futile quests for security amid emotional barrenness.
हिंदी सारांश (संक्षिप्त)
एक शानदार लेकिन पैसे की चिंता से ग्रस्त घर में, एक सुंदर लेकिन दुर्भाग्यपूर्ण माँ अपूर्ण प्रेम और आर्थिक चिंता से जूझती है, जो "और पैसा चाहिए!" की अनकही फुसफुसाहट से सताई जाती है। उसका बेटा पॉल, इस कमी को महसूस कर, खुद को भाग्यशाली घोषित करता है और रॉकिंग-हॉर्स पर सवारी कर दौड़ के विजेताओं का अनुमान लगाता है, माली बैसेट और चाचा ऑस्कर के साथ गुप्त सट्टेबाजी में भागीदार बनकर धन कमाता है।
पॉल की उन्मादी सवारी डैफोडिल और लाइवली स्पार्क जैसे विजेताओं की भविष्यवाणी करती है, जो हजारों पाउंड कमाते हैं, जो गुप्त रूप से माँ को वार्षिक किस्तों में दिए जाते हैं। फिर भी, उसकी अतृप्त इच्छाएँ फुसफुसाहट को बढ़ाती हैं, डर्बी से पहले पॉल को हताश कर देती हैं। अति-उत्तेजित, वह ट्रांस में गिर जाता है, डेलीरियम में मलाबार को विजेता नामित करता है। घोड़ा जीतता है, अस्सी हजार पाउंड दिलाता है, लेकिन पॉल ब्रेन-फीवर से मर जाता है, उसकी बलिदानी "भाग्य" भौतिकवाद की दुखद कीमत उजागर करता है।
कहानी लालच के मनोवैज्ञानिक प्रभाव की आलोचना करती है, रॉकिंग-हॉर्स भावनात्मक बंजरता के बीच सुरक्षा की व्यर्थ खोज का प्रतीक है।
Reprint 2025-26
Plot Summary: Key Events & Structure
Overview
A psychological tragedy unfolds through whispers of greed, culminating in a child's sacrificial frenzy. Central conflict: Familial emotional void vs. illusory luck via gambling, symbolizing materialism's destructive pursuit.
Structure in Phases
- Exposition: Mother's unluck and house's haunting whisper; Paul's quest for luck (Opening family dynamics).
- Rising Action: Rocking-horse trances predict winners; secret partnerships yield fortunes, anonymous gift to mother.
- Climax: Mother's full advance escalates whispers; Paul's Derby frenzy leads to collapse and Malabar revelation.
- Resolution: Massive win, but Paul's death—ironic wealth amid loss.
Points to Ponder
- Symbolism: Rocking-horse = obsessive divination; whispers = insatiable desire.
- Narrative Voice: Omniscient third-person, delving into psychic undercurrents.
- Cultural Insight: Edwardian class pressures, Freudian undertones of repressed emotion.
Tip: Note ironic circularity—begins with unluck, ends with "lucky" death.
Understanding the Text
1. What was the reason for young Paul’s restlessness at the beginning of the story? How did it find expression?
- Paul's restlessness stems from the pervasive "whisper" of financial insufficiency haunting the house, internalized as emotional guilt from his mother's unloving facade and the family's pretentious lifestyle. This unspoken anxiety—"There must be more money!"—creates a psychic pressure, sensed by the children as a grinding fault they must remedy.
- It manifests in Paul's obsessive rocking-horse rides: frenzied, trance-like gallops "charging madly into space," eyes "glaring" with "strange" intensity, seeking "luck" to silence the voices. This ritualistic behavior evolves into prophetic divination of race winners, a desperate bid to fulfill the maternal void through material success.
- Symbolically, his "stealthy" inward quest and isolation from siblings underscore psychological isolation, foreshadowing self-destructive mania. Lawrence links this to Oedipal tension—Paul's "brazen" claim of luck challenges paternal failure, expressing via gambling a child's futile heroism.
2. Why do you think Paul’s mother was not satisfied with the yearly birthday gift of 1,000 pounds for five years?
- The mother's dissatisfaction reveals her deeper malaise: not mere poverty, but a profound sense of personal failure and unluck, where money symbolizes validation. The structured gift, though generous, imposes restraint on her "expensive tastes," clashing with her desire for immediate, ostentatious luxury to affirm social superiority.
- Psychologically, it exacerbates her "hard little place" of unlovable self-doubt; partial relief fuels the whispers' escalation into "mad" ecstasy, demanding "more than ever!" Her interview demanding full advance underscores insatiable greed—money as surrogate for love she cannot feel, perpetuating the cycle of anxiety.
- Thematically, Lawrence critiques bourgeois materialism: the gift's anonymity denies her agency, while its insufficiency against debts highlights how wealth amplifies spiritual emptiness, driving Paul's fatal quest.
3. What was the reason for the anxiety of Paul’s mother as he grew older?
- The mother's anxiety arises from intuitive "seizures" of dread about Paul's fragility—his "uncanny" eyes, frail frame, and obsessive racing fixation signal impending breakdown, evoking her own repressed guilt over unloving motherhood and the house's toxic whispers she unwittingly perpetuates.
- As Paul matures beyond nursery control, his secrecy (hidden bets, solitary rides) mirrors her concealed emotional barrenness, fostering a mirrored torment: she senses his "nerves" as extensions of familial damage, compounded by her gambling heritage's shadow.
- Climactically, her party-time anguish—rushing to phone—reveals maternal instinct clashing with "common sense," underscoring Lawrence's theme of intuitive bonds severed by materialism, her "heart curiously heavy" foreshadowing tragic loss.
4. Paul’s final bet made the family rich but cost him his life. Explain.
- Paul's Derby trance yields Malabar's win at 14:1 odds, netting over 80,000 pounds via partners' stakes—a fortune silencing whispers temporarily, securing family wealth and ironic "luck" his mother craved, yet his exhaustive frenzy triggers fatal brain-fever, collapsing mid-revelation.
- This sacrifice exposes the story's irony: Paul's "absolute" surety, born of Oedipal drive to redeem maternal unluck, destroys him—physical toll of "madly surging" rides symbolizes emotional vampirism, where child's psychic labor feeds adult avarice.
- Thematically, Lawrence indicts greed's human cost: Riches arrive postmortem, Uncle Oscar's lament—"eighty-odd thousand to the good, and a poor devil of a son to the bad"—crystallizing tragedy, Paul's death as ultimate, futile "winner" in a luckless cycle.
Talking about the Text - Discussion Prompts
Discuss in pairs or small groups
1. ‘Luck is necessary for success in life’.
- Paul's mantra—"better to be born lucky than rich"—inverts meritocracy, yet his "manufactured" luck via frenzy questions fate vs. effort. Explore: Does modern "hustle culture" echo this, where perceived luck (e.g., viral success) trumps skill?
- Critique: Mother's unluck as self-fulfilling prophecy perpetuates failure; Paul's death shows luck's illusionary salve for deeper voids. Real-world: Lottery winners' post-win depressions parallel the story's ironic fortune.
- Counter: Bassett's "sure as eggs" caution suggests strategy over chance. Personal: Share "lucky" breaks—were they truly random, or prepared minds?
- Extension: Debate socioeconomic "luck"—privilege as invisible fortune in unequal societies.
2. Although Paul’s mother liked to be rich she did not approve of betting on horses.
- Hypocrisy: Mother's "gambling family" disdain masks her own risk in sketches and debts, projecting shame onto Paul while craving fruits. Discuss: How does class morality sanitize personal vices?
- Psychological: Her opposition stems from control loss—bets as chaotic luck she lacks—yet she demands full advance, revealing selective ethics. Modern parallel: Anti-gambling parents funding lotteries.
- Consequences: Prohibition would halt Paul's mania, but whispers' root (her unloving heart) persists. Solutions: Open dialogue on desires vs. taboos.
- Creative: Rewrite scene where she discovers bets—empathy or condemnation?
3. What were the voices that Paul heard? Did they lead him to success in the real sense?
- Voices: Metaphysical manifestation of familial avarice—unspoken "There must be more money!" echoing from toys, horse, cushions—as psychological haunt, not supernatural but internalized guilt.
- "Success": Financial windfall, yet pyrrhic—drives mania, isolation, death; true success eludes as emotional bonds fracture, mother remains "hard-hearted." Lawrence: Material gain corrupts spiritual wholeness.
- Broaden: Echo in consumer culture's "never enough"—social media FOMO as modern whispers. Reflection: When has pursuit of "more" undermined joy?
- Extension: Symbolic reading—voices as societal pressure on youth for provision.
Appreciation & Analysis
1. Examine the communication channels in the story between a. Paul and his mother b. Paul and Bassett c. Paul and his uncle d. Bassett and Paul’s uncle e. Paul’s mother and his uncle.
- a. Paul-Mother: Fractured, nonverbal—mutual "cold" gazes reveal unloving truth; Paul's secretive luck hides from her, her anxiety via "seizures" unspoken, culminating in tragic intrusion.
- b. Paul-Bassett: Ritualistic, conspiratorial—shared "religious" racing yarns foster bond; Bassett's deference ("as if from heaven") enables Paul's mania without challenge.
- c. Paul-Uncle: Avuncular, honor-bound—"Honour bright" pacts build trust; uncle's amusement evolves to nervousness, yet enables via partnership, masking concern.
- d. Bassett-Uncle: Deferential, mediated—Bassett's church-like gravity relays Paul's "surety," uncle's probing yields alliance, highlighting adult complicity.
- e. Mother-Uncle: Pragmatic, indirect—lawyer as proxy for gift; post-death lament reveals shared irony, uncle voicing critique she internalizes.
- Overall: Lawrence contrasts verbal silences with psychic "whispers," underscoring isolation in "superior" facades.
2. How has the author linked the symbol of the rocking-horse to Paul’s triumphs at the races?
- The rocking-horse embodies Paul's escapist divination: "charging madly into space" trances mimic race gallops, transforming childish toy into prophetic oracle—"take me to where there is luck."
- Linked triumphs: Frenzied rides yield names (Sansovino, Daffodil, Malabar), "forced" surety via whip-slashing paralleling bets' intensity; horse's "glassy-bright" eye mirrors Paul's "blazing" gaze, fusing play with mania.
- Symbolically: Phallic/Oedipal—straddling asserts paternal rivalry; mechanical "careering" critiques illusory control, triumphs as self-consuming fire, ending in fatal "surge."
- Lawrence's mastery: Evolves from nursery haunt to bedroom secret, amplifying isolation, triumphs' hollowness revealed in death-crash.
3. The ending of the story is an instance of irony. Suppose Paul had not died at the end, how would you have reacted to the story?
- Irony: Paul's "luck" delivers riches but claims his life—Uncle's "eighty-odd thousand to the good, and a poor devil of a son to the bad" twists success into tragedy, exposing greed's pyrrhic victory.
- Alternate survival: Reaction shifts from poignant catharsis to ambiguous satire—continued wins might satirize endless avarice, but dilute pathos; Paul's institutionalization or breakdown could heighten psychological horror, yet lose sacrificial purity.
- Personal: Without death, less urgency in critique; survival might evoke pitying hope (therapy, maternal awakening), but weaken thematic punch—irony's sting lies in finality, mirroring life's unluck.
- Broader: Echoes Victorian moral tales; survival risks melodrama, death ensures modernist subtlety.
Language Work
1. ‘A bird in hand is worth two in the bush’.
One certain gain is better than two uncertain ones—prefer secure possession over risky pursuit.
b. Story Context:Uncle Oscar urges caution: Advance full 5,000 now (bird in hand) over future bets (bush), yet Paul's optimism inverts, leading to tragedy—highlights greed's folly.
c. Hindi Proverb:हाथी के दांत खाने के और, दिखाने के और (similar: showy risks vs. practical gain).
2. Explain the following phrases: Sure as eggs / Spinning yarns / Turned to dust. Use them in sentences of your own.
- Sure as eggs: Absolutely certain (like eggs hatching). Ex: "Her alibi was sure as eggs; no doubt remained."
- Spinning yarns: Telling exaggerated tales. Ex: "The sailors spent evenings spinning yarns of sea monsters."
- Turned to dust: Failed or disintegrated (like dreams). Ex: "His grand plans turned to dust after the market crash."
3. Dictionary Meanings: Facial Expressions
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Smile | To form one's features into a pleased, kind, or amused expression, typically with lips curved up. |
| Grin | To smile broadly, often showing teeth, in amusement or embarrassment. |
| Grimace | To make an ugly, twisted expression on the face, typically to show disgust or pain. |
| Sneer | To smile or speak in a contemptuous or mocking manner. |
Reprint 2025-26
Interactive Quiz - Test Your Understanding
10 MCQs on plot, themes, and language. Aim for 80%+.
Suggested Reading
- Sun and Moon by Katherine Mansfield.
Reprint 2025-26
Group Discussions
No forum posts available.
Easily Share with Your Tribe


